American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. (AII) Insider Trading

Last 12 months

Insiders bought $200k and sold $30.9M on the open market.

57% of the selling was scheduled in advance under 10b5-1 plans. Chief Executive Officer Robert C Ritchie sold $9.03M on Nov 21, 2025, 16% of their stake, outside a plan.

Net open-market

−$30.7M

3 buys · 16 sales

Under a 10b5-1 plan

57%

of the value sold

Insiders who bought / sold

3 / 2

executives and directors

Last open-market buy

May 2026

May 26, 2026

Get an email when AII's executives or directors buy, or make a large sale outside a plan.

Trades · last 2 years

Date	Insider	Trade	Shares	Price	Value	Of their stake	Filing
Oct 14	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan	26,436	$27.23	$720k	1.5%	Form 4
Oct 9 – 13	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan 3 parts	123,564	$27.24 average	$3.37M	6.6%	Form 4
Aug 31	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan	9,174	$25.92	$238k	0.5%	Form 4
Aug 28	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan	6,000	$26.50	$159k	0.3%	Form 4
Aug 26 – 27	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan 2 parts	64,365	$26.59 average	$1.71M	3.3%	Form 4
Aug 24 – 25	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan 2 parts	110,461	$26.29 average	$2.9M	5.3%	Form 4
Aug 20 – 21	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan 3 parts	59,614	$25.33 average	$1.51M	2.8%	Form 4
Aug 18 – 19	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan 2 parts	18,000	$25.31 average	$456k	0.8%	Form 4
Aug 14 – 17	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan 2 parts	75,402	$24.70 average	$1.86M	3.4%	Form 4
Aug 12 – 13	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan 3 parts	88,260	$23.40 average	$2.07M	3.8%	Form 4
Aug 10	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan	5,800	$20.72	$120k	0.2%	Form 4
Aug 6 – 7	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan 2 parts	49,924	$20.88 average	$1.04M	2.1%	Form 4
Aug 3 – 4	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	Sold10b5-1 plan 2 parts	63,000	$20.76 average	$1.31M	2.6%	Form 4
Jun 5 – 9	Sowell Investments Holding Co., LLC Large holder	Bought 3 parts	136,356	$16.88 average	$2.3M	3.0%	Form 4
May 26	Steven B Mathis Director	Bought	3,000	$16.82	$50k	96%	Form 4
May 22	Steven E Smathers Director	Bought	2,900	$16.99	$49k	1.7%	Form 4
May 22	David Lewis Clark Chairman	Bought	5,830	$17.15	$100k	1.2%	Form 4
Dec 5, 2025	Sowell Investments Holding Co., LLC Large holder	SoldNo plan	295,037	$19.00	$5.61M	6.2%	Form 4
Dec 5, 2025	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	SoldNo plan	59,554	$19.00	$1.13M	2.4%	Form 4
Nov 21, 2025	Robert C Ritchie Chief Executive Officer	SoldNo plan	475,000	$19.00	$9.03M	16%	Form 4
Nov 21, 2025	James E Sowell Large holder	SoldNo plan	2,353,200	$19.00	$44.7M	33%	Form 4
Nov 21, 2025	Steven E Smathers Director	SoldNo plan	171,800	$19.00	$3.26M	50%	Form 4
May 13, 2025	Steven E Smathers Director	SoldNo plan	98,385	$16.00	$1.57M	22%	Form 4
May 13, 2025	James E Sowell Large holder	SoldNo plan	524,070	$16.00	$8.39M	6.9%	Form 4
May 9, 2025	Steven E Smathers Director	SoldNo plan	245,216	$16.00	$3.92M	36%	Form 4

Oct 1410b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 26,436 at $27.23
$720k
1.5% of stake
Oct 9 – 1310b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 123,564 at avg $27.24
$3.37M
6.6% of stake
Aug 3110b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 9,174 at $25.92
$238k
0.5% of stake
Aug 2810b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 6,000 at $26.50
$159k
0.3% of stake
Aug 26 – 2710b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 64,365 at avg $26.59
$1.71M
3.3% of stake
Aug 24 – 2510b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 110,461 at avg $26.29
$2.9M
5.3% of stake
Aug 20 – 2110b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 59,614 at avg $25.33
$1.51M
2.8% of stake
Aug 18 – 1910b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 18,000 at avg $25.31
$456k
0.8% of stake
Aug 14 – 1710b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 75,402 at avg $24.70
$1.86M
3.4% of stake
Aug 12 – 1310b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 88,260 at avg $23.40
$2.07M
3.8% of stake
Aug 1010b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 5,800 at $20.72
$120k
0.2% of stake
Aug 6 – 710b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 49,924 at avg $20.88
$1.04M
2.1% of stake
Aug 3 – 410b5-1 plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 63,000 at avg $20.76
$1.31M
2.6% of stake
Jun 5 – 9
Sowell Investments Holding Co., LLC
Large holder · bought 136,356 at avg $16.88
$2.3M
3.0% of stake
May 26
Steven B Mathis
Director · bought 3,000 at $16.82
$50k
96% of stake
May 22
Steven E Smathers
Director · bought 2,900 at $16.99
$49k
1.7% of stake
May 22
David Lewis Clark
Chairman · bought 5,830 at $17.15
$100k
1.2% of stake
Dec 5, 2025No plan
Sowell Investments Holding Co., LLC
Large holder · sold 295,037 at $19.00
$5.61M
6.2% of stake
Dec 5, 2025No plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 59,554 at $19.00
$1.13M
2.4% of stake
Nov 21, 2025No plan
Robert C Ritchie
Chief Executive Officer · sold 475,000 at $19.00
$9.03M
16% of stake
Nov 21, 2025No plan
James E Sowell
Large holder · sold 2,353,200 at $19.00
$44.7M
33% of stake
Nov 21, 2025No plan
Steven E Smathers
Director · sold 171,800 at $19.00
$3.26M
50% of stake
May 13, 2025No plan
Steven E Smathers
Director · sold 98,385 at $16.00
$1.57M
22% of stake
May 13, 2025No plan
James E Sowell
Large holder · sold 524,070 at $16.00
$8.39M
6.9% of stake
May 9, 2025No plan
Steven E Smathers
Director · sold 245,216 at $16.00
$3.92M
36% of stake

How to read this. Insiders sell for many reasons: taxes, diversifying, a house. Open-market buys are rarer and say more. A 10b5-1 plan is a trading schedule set up months in advance, so those sales were not timed on news. Large holders (funds and 10% owners) are listed under Everything but not counted as insiders. If you own or watch AII, we send a push when an executive buys or makes a large sale outside a plan.

Source: SEC Form 4 filings, filed within two business days of each trade and checked for new ones every hour.

Related stocks: Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance

AMSFAmerisafe Inc.

ACICAmerican Coastal Insurance Corp.

NODKNi Holdings Inc.

KINSKingstone Companies Inc.

GBLIGlobal Indemnity Group LLC

HIPOHippo Holdings Inc.

ASICAtegrity Specialty Holdings

KFSKingsway Financial Services Inc.

Spot a number that looks wrong? Check it in AII's SEC filings or

Download this analysis as a PDF (Pro)

Data sourced from SEC EDGAR filings and third-party price providers. Scores, valuations, and metrics are algorithmic estimates. This is not investment advice. See our Terms and Methodology.

2 of 2 free stocks used today

Keep analysing AII

Create a free account and get 14 days of Premium: every stock and every tool.

Unlimited stocksQuality, fair value and dividends for 10,000+ stocks
Stock screenerFilter on quality, valuation and dividend safety
Portfolio trackerReal return, dividend calendar and portfolio quality
Editable DCFChange the assumptions and watch fair value move
Compare side by sideUp to 10 stocks in one table
Unlimited alertsPrice, P/E, Quality Score and yield

No card. Moves to Free after, unless you upgrade.

Already have an account?

Or come back tomorrow. Stocks on your watchlist are always free to view.